ChezGigi

Fractured Fallacies of a Finagling Fact Finder and Obfuscating Humorist

Welcome to ChezGigi.com!

  • Subscribe to the site and I promise never to reveal your personal info to anyone. Unless your mom calls and says she hasn't heard from you in three weeks. Then, you're on your own. You should call your mom. Write your name and email and we can be BFFs.  Blog Friends Forever.

  • Aenean et nibh rutrum, faucibus sapien non, placerat lectus.
 
 

A Woman's Guide To The Universe, Internet Stuff

How Do Quora And Medium Compare? An Interview With A Person

Quora and Medium. Shall I compare them to a summer’s day? It’s instructive to note that Will Shakespeare lived in England when he wrote this, where comparing a girl to a summer’s day was more romantic than if he’d lived in Florida of the Armpit Climate. If he’d lived in Vegas, he’d be saying she was one hot number.

I’ve been over at Medium for awhile. I haven’t written consistently until recently. I wrote a post last night from a lifted Quora question in an experiment with illegal activities, because I’m such a badass. We’re not supposed to do that, because Quora owns those question, doncha know.

That’s right; Quora owns them and the alphabet they rode in on, bucko. Before you call the cops, I changed it up a bit. Put the phone down.

A bunch of Quora users have opened accounts on Medium. I understand why, and I know why they haven’t been active, yet, or not more than a post or two. I’m following all of them as I find them, because I would hope that we can create a vibrant community there, just as we have on Quora.

quora and medium on chezgigi.com

They’re concerned Quora won’t last for very long. To write a lot of content for a platform, for it to just disappear, like soap bubbles popping in the air, is disheartening.

Scott Welch wrote an excellent piece on Quora’s life expectancy.  The users are in the Matrix, the unconscious dwellers of some hive, willing to endlessly work under oppressive conditions, and even letting other dwellers nibble at our flesh while we continue to churn out answers.

I’m referring of course, to the ease with which Quora lets groups of users target and attack another writer. We will call them Loser Users to satisfy the seventh grader in my soul. I’m sure they fill some purpose. The oppression is real; there’s often a feeling that there’s an entity standing behind you, ready to collapse and ding you for your content.

One Quora writer reminded me yesterday that drafts are saved AS we write them, and almost before he could submit a post yesterday, it was collapsed. Is that creepy or what?

Oh, my. This is too close to my reality on Quora.

Yesterday, Quora implemented a ‘Thank you for the upvote’ feature, so now in addition to having just plain upvotes and comments in your notifications, you now have ‘Thank yous’.

No one seems to like it, but Medium has given its users the Clap. You can clap as often as you like for something, and each time you do, little red dots burst out of your hands, like you’re squashing bloated mosquitoes. So you get a Thank you, and the Clap. In that order.

Quora has also hidden the comments of those people whom you have blocked, or who have blocked you. It looks now as if people are talking to themselves, like those wandering denizens of the streets we still see muttering about government spies and aliens, only without a cell phone attached to their ear.

We are to be spared the very sight of our enemies, as if what we don’t see won’t hurt us, very apropos of modern society, but we still cannot flit about leaving disrespectful jabs, just because we know the person can’t see our comments. Everyone else will be able to.

Medium will make more of an impression as time goes on, but for now, it feels clean and quiet. Like when you’re on vacation, and your room is an unholy mess when you leave to go sightseeing, but when you return it’s all in order? Yeah, like that.

Or you’ve moved into a new house, and there are no posters, pictures, knick knacks, scuffs on the wall, or clothes on the floor in the new room. It’s free from unsavory history and old baggage.

The neighbors are unknown quantities, too. They might be the most obnoxious neighbors ever invented, but you don’t know that when you first move in. They don’t know you, either. This is the reason kids cleave to their peers when they reach their teens.  Their friends don’t whip out pictures of them on the potty when they were two, or have any but fresh expectations of them.

I remember starting out on Quora. It felt like no one would ever read my stuff. I kept at it, because the questions are prompts, and for reasons I can’t fathom, they often set off a sparkling fuse of creativity. Medium isn’t a Q and A platform, making it closer in nature to my own blog.

I don’t write about depression, illness, abuse, egregious politics and antics, or editorials, nor do I have a very commercialized blog. Still, I kept writing posts on my blog, and gradually it’s become more searchable, as I’ve become familiar with SEO. I’m considering advertising it. I want my stories and books to be found. For both Medium and Quora, I have to depend on their commercialization and SEO results.

Both platforms allow for the posting of products, or links to other websites, more so on Medium. Quora allows it on the profile page. Medium doesn’t seem to have anyone peering at what we’re doing, our comments, content, links, images, nothing. It’s very freeing, just as it is on my own blog.

On both platforms, friends can be made, which I really enjoy, as much as I enjoy writing. There must be a popularity rating, which can be seen in the numbers of followers writers have. That sometimes convinces me that they are consistently erudite, charming, funny, informative.

One thing I really like about Medium is that comments show up like posts. You can see them on your profile page. That’s an interesting feature, and comments can lead people to find your profile page and read your postings.

I’m experiencing this right now, so I’ll add it: Quora is constantly down! I haven’t seen that yet on Medium. A friend just asked me today what I made of his diminishing views, and I suggested that perhaps the news being so awful all the time, users have left to see what’s happening, leaving the screen door swinging, letting the flies and trolls in. Now I think it’s the frequency of ‘504 Gateway Errors’.

I’ve had such a problem lately with moderation on Quora, and have been hearing about the same ones and worse from other users on the site, that by contrast, Medium feels like America must have felt to refugees from the Soviet Union, or at the very least, when your parents were gone for a weekend.

“You mean, I can say what I want, post infographics and memes if I feel like it? I can jump up and down on the beds and yell at the top of voice? I can state an opinion and no one will throw me out of the country? Woo hoo!”

 

 

 

 

 

Please follow and like us:
RSS
Follow by Email
Facebook
Google+
https://chezgigi.com/2017/08/28/how-do-quora-and-medium-compare/
Twitter

22 Comments

  1. Mickey

    Hilerious and informative. I actually wasn’t aware of some of this, Gigi, and I’ll be checking out the links. I’m not very active on Medium, I mostly read your stuff, but I’ll look for some familiar names when I get the chance.
    Later Tater. Tch.

  2. Wolfman

    Good one My Love. Why would anyone stay where they are not wanted by management. Maybe the new site you speak of (medium) is the answer.
    Just enjoy yourself and don’t let the Trolls in life get you down.
    Love you Baby

    • You know about Trolls! Thank you, honey. I know all this nonsense has seemed very silly to you, and it is. But into each life, some trolls must fall, and splat at your feet.

  3. Mike Van Horn

    Good to see you on Medium, Gigi! I’ve been there about a year. I do different things:
    On Quora, I love to answer questions asked by others, and I sometimes ask my own. Stuff related to my science fiction, but also economic development. Nothing humorous like your material.
    On Medium, I post my stories. I started putting my science fiction short stories in another publication, The Rabbit Is In. Recently I’ve launched a blog called Marketing Mastery, related to my work. Sci fi is more fun, as my profile states.
    I think I’m going to have to launch another publication for my sci fi novel, starting with the one I sent you. Serialize it a chapter at a time.

    • Sounds good. Please post links so I can find you everywhere. Especially on Medium. I have a feeling a lot of people are there.

  4. Mike Van Horn

    You mentioned the possibility of Quora going under. I have several years worth of material there. I have to go back and save all that as Word docs, so it can’t disappear.
    I had that happen once before, back when LinkedIn had Q&A forums, then announced they were eliminating them. I went back and captured all my writing, and there was a lot of it. Mostly baloney, but some good stuff. Same with Quora. I value my own creativity. I don’t give a shit about what others say.

    • That’s a good idea, Mike. I’ve been deleting and migrating all day. Still have 800 some answers up. A lot I didn’t care about, and a lot I do. I won’t be on Quora much, but won’t leave entirely. I’ll follow you on Medium. So good to see you here!

  5. Ranne

    Went into Medium and read some of your pieces! No comments yet – I don`t like to rush my cleverness (lol). I just hope you don`t have your trolls chasing you there as well. Then it will feel like another gulag… X

    • I have a rocket launcher, and they’d better not. I don’t even think Medium has a policy through which writers can be targeted. Quora’s policy is just a weapon for the grudge ridden. It’s ridiculous over there. And then they accused me of plagiarism because I don’t write in APA format??? Kiss my grenade.

      They essentially accused me of theft because I didn’t put some quoted song lyrics, with a link, in block quotes.

      I know you sent me an email. I have to go read it. It’s taking me all week to delete my answers from Quora.

  6. Nancy Jacobsen

    I’m trying to figure out Medium too. So far my strategy is to follow as many familiar names as I can and hope that somehow that accomplishes something, although what that might be, I don’t know.

    I think my main problem with Medium is that I don’t have a sense of *coherence* like I do on Quora.

    • That’s because Medium is like my blog; you’re on your own for something to write about. I look for inspiration in the questions on Quora, and then change them up. Or whatever I feel like writing, which is nice, too. Having all the Quora users follow each other will create a built in community of users, Nancy. It’s a fresh start for people like me. Medium is not going to be a place where users can harass each other in secret. Not as far as I can tell, anyway. Time will tell us that, but I don’t think so.

  7. Mike Van Horn

    My advice for Medium: 1. Join an existing publication that already has a bunch of members. 2. Start your own publication.
    I’ve joined several that fit my interests. I’ve started one (on marketing for small business) and I’m about to start one for my science fiction stories.

    • That’s good advice, Mike. I think people like the community, and a private blog doesn’t really provide one. People can read and comment, but not write or read other people’s stuff. I can understand that.

      • Mike Van Horn

        Well, why don’t you put this blog on Medium?

        • I didn’t know I could do that, Mike. I do want to keep it independent. I’ve had enough of Quora telling me what to do. I’ll investigate and find out how that works.

          • Mike Van Horn

            Here’s a link to our marketing advice blog. https://medium.com/marketing-mastery. Not nearly as interesting as your posts!
            I see no sign that Medium interferes in any way with these publications. This, like anything else online, can disappear, so always back them up.
            I find that it’s so much easier to post things on Medium that I neglect my WordPress blogs.

          • Thank you, Mike! I sometimes neglect it too, but since I’m planning to not be on Quora much, I hope that changes. I’ll check this out.

    • Nancy Jacobsen

      <> I can’t figure out how to do that! I’ve looked everywhere I can think of for instructions, but have come up empty so far. I want to join Quora Extension if that helps to steer me in the right direction.

      • Alexander made me an editor! I didn’t know it existed! I’ll post this right now, Nancy.

        • Nancy Jacobsen

          So how does one join? I really like that Quora-related authors are listed all in on place.

          • It’s been so long, I can’t remember. I think it’s as simple as Quora, logging in with FBook or something. Just to to Medium.com, and register there, Nancy. It’s easy. I just saw Nick Nicholas there, too.

Leave a Reply

Theme by Anders Norén

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)